A simple guide to the notification of professional indemnity insurance claims and claim circumstances

All professional indemnity insurance policies incorporate a 'conditions precedent' which imposes a duty on you to notify insurers of:

  • Any communication whether in writing or oral intimating a claim or an intention to make a claim against you arising from any professional neglect in the conduct of your business, or for any loss which may be covered by the policy
  • Any circumstances which may give rise to a claim against you
  • In addition any notification of a claim or circumstance should be made immediately and before expiry of the policy otherwise there is a substantial risk that insurers may refuse to indemnify you

Problems can arise in identifying what is a ‘claim’ or ‘circumstance’ and the example definitions below may assist.

‘Claim’

“Claim means a demand for, or an assertion of a right to, civil compensation or civil damages or an intimation of an intention to seek such compensation or damages”

‘Circumstances’

“Circumstances means an incident, occurrence, fact, matter, act or omission which may give rise to a claim in respect of civil liability.”

When considering whether to notify a circumstance you should ignore:

  • The amount of any loss - even matters which clearly fall below your policy excess should be notified
  • Whether the facts as stated are accurate
  • Your own personal views on any liability

If you have to think about whether you should notify or not then notify.

If a claim is made against you, please remember that when dealing with the claimant or their representatives you must not:-

  • Make any admissions of liability
  • Make any offers of settlement without the prior agreement of insurers
  • Disclose to any party that you have notified your professional indemnity insurers

There are legal protocols applying to all professional negligence claims which impose time constraints and procedural rules as to how claims should be dealt with. It is most important that claims are notified immediately.

A PDF version of this claim and claim circumstance guide can be found on the right hand side of this page.